The YouTuber-turned-fighter's jaw dropped wide open, his expression turning to huge glazed saucers as he collapsed to the canvas in shock and awe after a devastating right hand from the former champion. It looked as if Paul was trying to utter "Wow!" as the severity of the impact registered to his rattled senses.
"Those watching didn't spend money to see this crap," said the referee, summing up the dismal spectacle much more effectively than any observer else could.
Trapped in a corner of the ring in the middle of the sixth round, Paul could no longer retreat or hold on to Joshua's legs like a forlorn little boy as the serious reality of boxing became clear. Instead, as he tried to absorb the punch that broke his jaw in two distinct locations, Paul was caught in an utterly stunned moment.
So this is how it is like, and looks, to be struck cleanly by a genuine boxer, an Olympic gold medallist and ex- world heavyweight champion. "Goodness" is certainly the appropriate term.
It was the fourth time the social media star had been knocked down, but the result of a proper punch meant Paul would not be able to rise and taunt his opponent before the official called the charade to a halt. As blood began to trickle from his lips, and a dull ache spread through his jawbone, Paul finally grasped how difficult, exhausting, and perilous boxing is at a decent standard of competition.
Anthony Joshua, it must be noted, was far from convincing amid the chaos. After his empty victory, he performed a cut-throat motion that hinted at a clinical and deadly finish when, in truth, Joshua had cut a frustrated figure for most of the contest. Instead of exuding intimidation or exhibiting an iron certainty, Joshua had appeared tentative and crude for nearly five stanzas.
Paul's lack of conditioning, which is a fundamental requirement in elite boxing, dictated the outcome. Lacking the stamina to escape any longer, and reduced to falling to the canvas as frequently as he could for a rest, Paul was left helpless by exhaustion. Joshua delivered the vicious finish, but, until then, he had looked like a mournful imitation of the boxer he had been in 2017.
"It wasn't the best display," Joshua admitted. "The objective was to get Jake Paul, pin him down and hurt him. That has been the request, and that's what was on my mind. It took a bit longer than expected, but the right hand finally reached its destination."
Joshua praised Paul's courage but he added an explanation for his own stilted performance. "He faced a genuine competitor tonight that's had a fifteen-month layoff," Joshua said, mentioning his last defeat. "We shook off the rust, and I can't wait to roll into 2026."
In the post-fight interview that followed, a cheerful Joshua tried out a woeful impression of Tyson Fury as he demanded a scrap against the presently inactive boxer. Joshua will probably get his wish, but that bout comes much too late in their professional journeys. Both men are on the far side of the hill.
In stark contrast, the most compelling heavyweights in the world are Oleksandr Usyk and Moses Itauma. Usyk remains the undoubted king of the weight class, after defeating both Joshua and Fury twice. At the same time, Itauma is a rapidly ascending talent. The youthful British heavyweight would probably have needed fewer than half the amount of rounds that Joshua required to knock Paul into a suitably wowed state.
But the public gets what the public desires, and that certainly means additional low-quality crossover contests. Paul appeared truly proud and brash to have had his mandible fractured by a hammer-like right. In the early hours of the next day, he posted an X-ray, with the two fractures marked in crimson.
That lighthearted reference to the Mexican superstar, a far greater boxer than Joshua but a similarly faded force, showed that Paul's brazen audacity remains undented. It may not be Canelo, but Paul will shortly find someone else with whom he can earn more than $50 million.
During his in-ring interview, before departing to the hospital, Paul expelled a tracer of blood onto the canvas. It was another grim summary of the night as Paul mixed harsh reality with gory bravado and stated: "I believe my jaw is broken. It's definitely broke. A proper ass-whipping from one of the best to ever step in the ring. I love this sport and I'm going to return and keep on winning."
Elena Hartwell is a tech enthusiast and lifestyle writer exploring the intersection of innovation and well-being.